|
As technology products mature and become commoditised and competition intensifies,
manufacturers are increasingly looking to electronic channels to bypass elements of
the supply chain and thereby retain a higher proportion of their margins. More than
often, it is the distributor's role within the channel that is most open to challenge
from these new electronic channels. After all, products need to be made by the
manufacturer and resellers have the relationships with the end-user. Yet, replacing
existing distributor partners with an Internet-based system may seem attractive from
a short-term financial perspective but in the long run this underestimates the role
of distributors and the value they bring to the supply chain.
Firstly, distributors play a vital role as intermediaries between globalised manufacturers
and localised resellers and end users. The fact is that distributors typically serve
regions that are more widespread than any reseller and yet have a strong understanding
of local circumstances. The sheer scale of logistical support required for effective
management of a global distribution process is beyond the scope of most manufacturers.
Distributors are therefore able to provide a 'buffering' function enabling global
manufacturers to more effectively meet demand on a regional basis.
Combined with this is the ability of distributors to provide manufacturers with valuable
market sizing information. The fact that resellers operate on a local level with small
product volumes means that they cannot serve as statistically valid indicators of future
demand. Furthermore, manufacturers deal with products across large geographies and thus
don't have the detailed insight into local market conditions that can yield accurate forecasts.
Distributors can aggregate resellers' sales into meaningful volumes and are therefore ideally
placed to provide market-sizing information which enables manufacturers to effectively balance
their product portfolios.
After all, manufacturers are geared to producing goods on a large scale consistently over
the year while customers only buy sporadically. To avoid large stock piles of products
taking up valuable warehouse space, distributors provide not only essential sales forecasting
information but also the logistical support necessary to keep goods flowing to where they
are needed.
In addition to manufacturers, distributors are also well placed to provide this sales analysis
to resellers. Through examining sales patterns and product life cycles, distributors can
deliver a crucial component of the reseller's information needs, which is essential if they
are to eliminate the prospect of 'fire sales' of obsolete equipment at the end of the working
life of the products they stock.
Distributors also play a valuable role in facilitating such tasks as returns management.
Inevitably products purchased by end users will be returned, which can often lead to a variety
of complex processes including testing, refurbishment, disposal or returning to the manufacturer.
Traditionally, the distributor will act as an intermediary between the manufacturer and reseller
or customer to ensure that the goods are received by the manufacturer and any rebates due are
passed on to the end user. Electronic channels simply cannot provide a replacement for the
complex processes distributors have set in place to handle returns.
Take for instance the recent European Union legislation compelling manufacturers to adopt
responsibility for recycling electronic goods. This means manufacturers are going to have to
implement processes for collecting these goods and then recycling them or alternatively paying
a reseller or distributor to undertake this. While electronic channels may be used by resellers
to procure goods from the manufacturers, they cannot effectively replace the role of the
distributor in the reverse supply channel.
Finally, distributors are increasingly providing a great deal of pre- and post-sales support,
particularly as a first line response to technical enquiries. Resellers typically don't sell
products in the kind of volume that would justify having product specialists on staff and they
therefore look further up the supply chain for that service. Manufacturers that argue in favour
of the removal of distributors from the supply chain have clearly given little thought to the
costs and resources that this level of technical support - on a 24/7 basis - would entail.
There can be little doubt that distributors have a great deal of value to offer the supply chain.
It is essential therefore that distributors threatened with removal from the supply chain stress
these and other benefits they can bring to both manufacturers and resellers. The ability to
provide sophisticated sales analysis and forecasting information, returns processes and technical
support should be at the heart of any dialogue a distributor has with a manufacturer. However, to
be in a position to provide these higher value services, distributors must invest in the necessary
technology solutions.
Unfortunately, it is too often the case that distributors are reluctant to make the necessary
investment. Sales forecasting, for instance, requires business information systems to provide
hard, statistical evidence while schemes such as returns management require sophisticated
back-end systems to automate processes within the supply chain. If distributors do not take
the necessary steps and invest in the required technology then they run the risk of becoming
irrelevant to the supply chain.
The temptation for manufacturers to replace elements of the supply chain with electronic
channels is perfectly understandable, especially in current economic conditions. Yet, while
cost savings may be forthcoming in the short term, the effect of so called disintermediation
(the removal of links from the supply chain) will certainly be more harmful in the long term.
To remove the role of the distributor from the supply chain is to ignore the inherent value
their role adds to both manufacturers and resellers.
|